Thursday, November 1, 2012

I need your opinions

Hello All!

I've been thinking about my Mirabilia Large-Stitch round robin. I wasn't sure if I was happy with the seaweed borders as I had them. I've tried a different look to the seaweed. I'd like to know if you like Version 1 seaweed better, or Version 2. Please keep in mind that the mermaids will be in their full regular color, not the silhouettes I've shown. Also, the black rectangular borders around each mermaid are just for placement.

Version 1

Version 2

Please share your opinions. Thank you!

11 comments:

Jo who can't think of a clever nickname said...

I prefer version 1 but I do think version 2 is more seaweedy!

Monique said...

I also like version 1 better even though it looks more like vines and not as seaweedy.

cucki said...

I like version 1 too :)

Melissa said...

I like version one better, but I agree with the others. It does not look as seaweedy.

Emma said...

I think I like version one better - but both work well! :)

Kathy A. said...

Option 1 for me.

tadamama said...

If seaweed is the look you're going for, I think #2 looks much more appropriate, but I do like the feel of #1 too!

rebeca. said...

I like version #1 as well even if it isn't as seaweedy. I like that it overlaps into the areas where the mermaids will be.

mytimestitching said...

I like version 1. I can't wait to watch this one grow. It is going to be BEAUTIFUL!

Jocelyn said...

I too like version 1 better. May I suggest adding some little treasures by the seaweed - like a starfish charm or a sand dollar or such? It would look so cute.

Number 2 looks more like seaweed - but it is more severe as a divider.

Susan said...

I'll be the odd one out, I prefer #2 as it does look more like seaweed. The mermaids are "substatial" and I think you need a similar feeling for the divider.